Patrick Warburton vs. H. Jon Benjamin

One voice… many characters?

During Comic-Con, I got to see two panels back-to-back, one with Patrick Warburton and the next with H. Jon Benjamin and it got me thinking–here are two talented voice actors who voice multiple characters, but they’ve really just got the one voice.

Among voice actors, Frank Welker is legendary for his ability to become a vocal chameleon. Listen to the opening of Rob Paulsen’s Talkin’ Toons Podcast and you’ll hear just a small sample of some of his different voices and characters. Tara Strong explores the full range of her voice, from the throaty, gravelly Raven to squeaky, high-pitched Bubbles. In his acting workshop, Bob Bergen stresses that there is a lot more to voice acting than just making with the funny voices. He teaches that the voice is nothing without a fully realized character behind it to bring the voice to life. So what does that mean for Patrick Warburton and H. Jon Benjamin? Is it okay that they don’t have a different voice for each of the characters they portray? Are they good enough actors to make their one voice work for a wide array of different characters?

I found a few samples of Patrick Warburton and H. Jon Benjamin in action so you can listen and decide for yourself. Do you think one of them is a better actor than the other?

First up: Patrick Warburton:

Family Guy – Joe Swanson


The Emperor’s New Groove – Kronk (Jump to 1:25)

The Venture Bros. – Brock Samson


Happily N’Ever After – Prince Humperdink


And now, H. Jon Benjamin:

Bob’s Burgers – Bob

Archer – Sterling Archer

Lucy: Daughter of the Devil – Satan

Dr. Katz – Ben Katz

So what do you think?

I have to admit, up to this point, I never gave PW a lot of thought. I kind of discounted him because he’s just got “the one voice.” I figured he was just doing the same thing over and over again under a different character name. Then I took a closer look at PW and his body of work. I gotta admit, while he tends to voice characters that are of a similar type (you know, big muscles, tiny brain), he finds a way to lend something different to each one so that it’s not just the same voice with a new name and a new face. I find each character unique and believable.

H. Jon Benjamin first came to my attention as Sterling Archer in the FX animated series “Archer.” He’s brilliant. The show is brilliant. I can’t get enough. Then I found out HJB was also on “Bob’s Burgers.” Whaaaa? Two primetime animated shows on two different networks simultaneously?? Wow, that’s impressive. So I watch “Bob’s Burgers.” I’m ready to fall in love with HJB all over again. Bob speaks and… wait a second… why is Archer’s voice coming out of that guy’s mouth?? It was weird, it was wrong, it just didn’t work for me. I was utterly disappointed. I’m not saying HJB is a bad actor, but I’m finding that I don’t love his voice acting outside of Archer. Maybe that’s just because Archer is such a great character and HJB has interpreted him perfectly.

So what do you think? Does one of these actors do a better job using their one voice for all their different characters? Can you think of any other actors who have one voice yet portray different roles? What’s more important to you: one really good voice or many great voices? Leave some comments and get the conversation rolling!

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Characters and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Patrick Warburton vs. H. Jon Benjamin

  1. John says:

    I’d say I like Warburton better to me he is much better at conveying emotion and his voice is more unique, while Benjamin he seems to rarely display emotion beyond sarcasm and his voice is nothing special I know several different guys who sound just like him and I can sound like him if I try hard enough.

  2. John Franson says:

    Don’t forget Warburton in The Tick and Benjamin in Home Movies. Those were my first exposures to both actors.

  3. Cia says:

    I love it Chuck, thanks! And thanks for including all of those samples!

  4. wouldchuck says:

    I forgot to mention a few others. In the classic voice over age, almost everyone was like Daws and Mel, Extremely versatile vocally, but, as I mentioned above there were a few with a much more limited vocal range. My favorite was Sterling (from my previous post) but there was also Wally Cox (although Underdog was his only voice-over character – all the rest were on camera), and to an extent Arnold Stang (one of his most famous roles was Top Cat, which was a little bit of a departure)
    Record

    Honey Nut Cheerios Bee

  5. wouldchuck says:

    There are a few classic actors that pop into my head who were LEGENDS with only one unique voice. The biggest one, and one of my all time favorites, was Sterling Holloway. He ranged from Winnie the Pooh to Kaa the Snake in Jungle Book. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001359/

    Kaa

    Winnie the Pooh

    Lambert the Sheepish Lion (narrator)

    Cheshire Cat

    And a live action role of his

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s